How to pick a quality memory foam pillow without trying it first

October 11, 2026 · 5 min read

Photo of a cream sofa with soft cushions and a throw in a bright living room

Memory foam pillows are loved for their steady, contouring support. Buying one online is convenient, but you can't press or lie on it first. Focus on these details to make a confident choice.

Loft: the most important number

  • Side sleepers need a medium-high to high pillow to keep the head level with the spine.
  • Back sleepers usually suit a medium height.
  • Stomach sleepers do best with a low, soft pillow.

Solid foam vs. shredded foam

A solid block offers even, consistent support. Shredded foam is softer and often adjustable, which is helpful if you're not sure of your ideal height.

A cover that breathes

Look for breathable fabrics, ventilation or cooling gel if you tend to sleep warm, and a removable, washable cover for easy care.

Reviews that actually help

  • Read reviews from people who sleep in your position.
  • Look for feedback after several months of use.
  • A light new-foam smell that fades in a day or two is normal.

Returns you can rely on

Comfort is personal, so check the store's returns window before you buy and keep the packaging until you're sure.

Pair with breathable bedding

Cotton sheets and pillowcases help keep you at a comfortable temperature, especially with memory foam.

Related departments